Is it just me, or is “Family Guy” one of the greatest shows of our time? And is it just me, or is it going downhill in a sad, stumbling way? Some of the most original, funniest, and wittiest writing I have seen from a network show (animated or otherwise) has come from “Family Guy” writers.
But lately it seems that Seth McFarland is falling out of love with the show that made him what he is, and is instead pouring his creative genius into a second-rate cartoon, namely “American Dad.” Granted I heard it has gotten a lot better since I stopped watching it (around episode one), but that can’t be difficult, considering how much it sucked.
I really don’t have much of a point here other than to gripe in public about the loss of vitality in “Family Guy” — so here’s more. By having Stewie bludgeon and in many other ways mutilate Brian last season, Seth showed that he really doesn’t care about the characters that he created anymore. The latest halfhearted attempt at a plot is even worse — a “simulation” which spanned two full episodes, while being self-aware about how much they were pissing off their fans.
The problem, in my never-humble opinion, is that Seth McFarland made it huge with “Family Guy” because he went with what he thought was amusing, and made the mistake of believing that just because he thought something was fun to do, others would agree. What made “Family Guy” great was that it broke boundaries, violated norms, and shocked people awake. It made us think. It challenged authority in a very serious way, but wrapped in a (sometimes paper-thin) humorous package.
The retarded “American Dad” concept took old, used up, and completely over-done ideas and tried to replicate the success of “Family Guy.” An alien with an accent that shouldn’t be on television from this millennium, a caricature of a caricature fish with a German accent, and brain-dead main characters should have prevented this show from getting any further than McFarland’s garbage can. But he was able to ride his “Family Guy” success (while betraying that creation) to fuel his childish passion for this partial-birth brain dump.
In closing, I’d like to thank Seth for the great time we all shared, and ask him to please stop now, before he embarrasses himself any further, and does any more damage to the remaining legacy of “Family Guy.”